“Repealing the Indian Act will mean little if Ottawa simply replaces it with a new set of race-based laws, privileges, bureaucracies, and political arrangements.”
In the early 2000's there was a strong proposal by the Federal Liberals to update and modernize the Indian Act, but even that was unacceptable, so it died!
Too many of the 600+ Chiefs are unwilling to give up power - even a little bit - so they will never vote to change it, let alone repeal it!
To really repeal the Indian Act, the Federal Government has to ignore the minority of self-interested nay-sayers and just do it - because it's the right thing to do, to stop this 'dangerous and dividing' law, based on race!
I don't know. These people have been trying to expand and enshrine racism since 2015. It's going to be hard for them to change!
But, it should be abolished as should Gladue and any court consideration of colour, race, religion, immigration status in handing out sentences. jobs and positions. DEI has to be made to be illegal. And the various aboriginal tribes should be treated as tribes, not nations. They should not be allowed to own half of a country they did not create, just because. And really they need to ditch all those reserves. That just maintains what should be viewed as antiquated and an embarrassment. All people pay taxes like everyone else, accept restrictions on hunting and fishing like everyone else was made to over time.
You are not going to get rid of racism by enshrining it. But you will expand it.
This is long overdue, but I agree with Carpay...it cannot be replaced with yet another program of race based supplementary arrangements. We have created a monster by giving & giving more, expecting absolutely nothing in return. Think about our own children. If you just give with no responsibility and no expectation for them to grow up and care for themselves, what have you done to them? That's actually abuse, not loving parenting.
After generations, these people only know hand outs. They believe it's their due and like our kids, it will be very hard to change. However, we need to start somewhere, because the monster has grown many heads and it has to stop, not just for our benefit, but more even for theirs. Their lives have only gotten worse under this system and it's time to find a road to better governance creating health & happiness for Indigenous people.
It will be a hard transition for the dependent of this largesse but necessary if they are going to succeed. Even their own are agreeing that in order to move forward it is time to chart something new. Start the talks and end the lawyers and consultants who are the primary recipients of a very rich income. Time to assimilate into the 21st century.
In the early 2000's there was a strong proposal by the Federal Liberals to update and modernize the Indian Act, but even that was unacceptable, so it died!
Too many of the 600+ Chiefs are unwilling to give up power - even a little bit - so they will never vote to change it, let alone repeal it!
To really repeal the Indian Act, the Federal Government has to ignore the minority of self-interested nay-sayers and just do it - because it's the right thing to do, to stop this 'dangerous and dividing' law, based on race!
Any person using the Indian Act or affirmative action programs should feel insulted.
Both are saying that you're not capable of competing in life on an equal basis with everyone else.
I don't know. These people have been trying to expand and enshrine racism since 2015. It's going to be hard for them to change!
But, it should be abolished as should Gladue and any court consideration of colour, race, religion, immigration status in handing out sentences. jobs and positions. DEI has to be made to be illegal. And the various aboriginal tribes should be treated as tribes, not nations. They should not be allowed to own half of a country they did not create, just because. And really they need to ditch all those reserves. That just maintains what should be viewed as antiquated and an embarrassment. All people pay taxes like everyone else, accept restrictions on hunting and fishing like everyone else was made to over time.
You are not going to get rid of racism by enshrining it. But you will expand it.
This is long overdue, but I agree with Carpay...it cannot be replaced with yet another program of race based supplementary arrangements. We have created a monster by giving & giving more, expecting absolutely nothing in return. Think about our own children. If you just give with no responsibility and no expectation for them to grow up and care for themselves, what have you done to them? That's actually abuse, not loving parenting.
After generations, these people only know hand outs. They believe it's their due and like our kids, it will be very hard to change. However, we need to start somewhere, because the monster has grown many heads and it has to stop, not just for our benefit, but more even for theirs. Their lives have only gotten worse under this system and it's time to find a road to better governance creating health & happiness for Indigenous people.
It will be a hard transition for the dependent of this largesse but necessary if they are going to succeed. Even their own are agreeing that in order to move forward it is time to chart something new. Start the talks and end the lawyers and consultants who are the primary recipients of a very rich income. Time to assimilate into the 21st century.
Agreed!
The mechanism used by Canadians to pass wealth from one generation to the next is PROPERTY.
.
Why the Hell does the CDN GOV'T make it impossible for Indigenous Canadians to own land on Reserves ???
.
THAT IS INCREDIBLY STUPID !!!
.