106 Comments
User's avatar
John's avatar

Vance knows that unchecked immigration in Canada is a threat to ALL OF North America, especially from China, the CCP, and Radical Islam.

Expand full comment
J Holden's avatar

So did Trudeau and does Carney.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 22
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
J Holden's avatar

From CBC & Gov of Canada

During Stephen Harper's time in office, the peak number of permanent residents admitted to Canada was just over 270,000. This was significantly lower than the immigration levels set by the subsequent Trudeau government, which aimed for higher annual targets.

CBC perspectivesjournal.ca

Canadian Immigration Limits Under Stephen Harper

Permanent Residents

Peak Year: The highest number of permanent residents admitted during Stephen Harper's tenure was just over 270,000 in 2012.

Average Admission: Throughout his time in office from 2006 to 2015, the annual admissions typically ranged between 250,000 to 270,000.

Refugees and Protected Persons

Percentage of Refugees: Approximately 10% of all permanent residents were resettled refugees and protected persons during Harper's government.

Temporary Workers and International Students

Temporary Foreign Workers: The Conservative government implemented stricter regulations on temporary foreign workers, which affected the number of permits issued.

International Students: The number of international students was also limited compared to later years under Justin Trudeau.

Summary of Immigration Policies

Harper's administration focused on tightening immigration rules, which included measures to reduce fraud and enhance security.

The government introduced policies that made it more challenging for certain groups, particularly refugees, to gain entry into Canada.

These limits and policies contributed to a significant shift in Canada's immigration landscape during Harper's time in office.

Expand full comment
Ner Ther's avatar

Let us not forget, the country was in a much different financial situation at the time and you bet that refugee claiments weren't able to get into Canada by an app on their phone. Without medical exams to boot.

Expand full comment
J Holden's avatar

Trudeau and Carney have made a mockery of our immigration system. Be assured that terrorists are arriving with the criminals and drugs/

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 22
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
J Holden's avatar

Immigration levels are definitely not alright with me. I pointed out Harper as he was the last of reasonable numbers and types. Per CBC.

Expand full comment
Brenda's avatar

MSM is the problem!! Voter perception and ignorance, created and guided by liberal partisan media. As well, now we have too many immigrants relying on liberal government handouts, who surely will not bite the hand that feeds them. To stay in power, or try to gain power, the politicians from all sides make sure they do not rile the most numerous groups of voters. Same reason Palestinians are allowed to take over the streets participating in demonstrations that are far from peaceful, in Montreal, Toronto, and other cities. We are in trouble. All part of the plan to muzzle and chain us.

Expand full comment
Ner Ther's avatar

Not many.

Expand full comment
Harold's avatar

Vance is a globalist puppet just like the rest. The detremental effects of mass immigration upon any nation is a no brainer. This is not immigation we are speaking about, it is a mass invasion; a military operation. If the USA would stop bombing the shit out of the middle east countries, and would stop using the dollar to commit acts of economic warfare around the globe (Tariffs, sanctions, etc) we wouldn't have mass migration to the west and hatred of the USA.

Expand full comment
Brent's avatar

you are painting with a very wide brush here. You make a solid argument, but you went off the rails. Canada's problem's started long before Trumps first term. Canada is in this position because of Canadians. Our situation has absolutely nothing to do with Trump or Vance. Canada's fall started post WWII with the deliberate implementation of socialism. Socialism is embedded in the physy of Canadians minds and today is proof of this evil operation. Canadians have been monitored and directed into this quagmire. Canadians apathy and compliance is the only blame here, nothing else, we did this to ourselves! "That Would Never Happen in Canada!"

Expand full comment
JosephPhallis's avatar

I suggest that you read the UN document on "Replacement Migration:

Is it A Solution to Declining and Ageing Populations?". It basically says that we don't multiply enough so they are going to help us out by Replacing us with the Third World. The document shows why the UN NGOs were in Costa Rica handing out maps food and money to the Millions of Migrants passing through there and once in the USA passing them on to other UN NGOs for assistance. The UN and the WEF are actively promoting this invasion into Western Countries. It will destroy us. (Nothing to do with Vance.)

Expand full comment
Brent's avatar

I agree, and I am sure we can agree there are many fundamentals that has created this mess in Canada, not only one...and none of them resulted because of Trump or Vance or the US for that matter...

Expand full comment
Harold's avatar

When you talk about Immigration, the USA's foreign policies are a major cause of the mass migration into the western world. If you are talking about Canada, our politcans adherences to the policies of foreign entities such as the USA, the UN, WTO, IPCC, IMF, WEF, NATO, and the WHO, are the cause of our lack of production and distribution, the inflated dollar, the collapse of our ecconomy, and the collapse of our judicial system.

A brief History:

Ontario was Canada's first oil field. In 1897, Ontario gave the ownership of that field to foreign investors; in 1905, Alberta did the same. Then In the 30's, there was the 10 drought that effected the western provinces, central USA, and Europe. In 1933, Judea along with the jewish leaders globaly, declared war against Germany; shortly thereafter, was WWII. (1939) In 1974, Canada's Central Bank was given to the Rothschilds'. The Rothchilds not only controlled Englands Central Bank , but the USA's central bank and now Canada's central Bank. Thereafter came NAFTA; an agreement designed for the foreign takeover of Canada's major production and distribution corporations. Later, our canadain owned wheat board was also handed over to foreign investors, CP rail and CN rail included. (Bill Gates a major share holder)

Foreign investor's own and control Canada. From 1897 forward, what have the conservatives or the liberals ever conserved? Canada's politcans - federal, provincial, and municiple, are nothing but puppets; they have never been anything other.

Expand full comment
Brent's avatar

I agree, but the US is not the only nation to be named along with all the other organization's you listed...all of the western European nations, Mediterranean nations, other south Asian nations, Aus. NZ. are also outside influences on policy, oh and Canada's international policy is also to blame - this is why it is called the UN, NATO, most conflicts are not just perpetrated by the US. I have never understood why Canadians have such disdain for the US! My point was the main topic, Canada's situation is not the fault solely due to Trump or his administration or the US...as you mentioned there are many fundamentals involved and to blame the US is misleading.

Expand full comment
GO's avatar

100% correct!... Canada fundamentally changed in the late 50's when the great turn to the Left started (endless empathy, socialization of all school systems and gov't agencies, feminization of culture)... and look where we are. This country is impotent. Our greatest threats are China and Islam (islamo/communism/fascism) , but because of the the weak "kindness" of our high trust western civilizational legal framework no one has the guts to make decisions that are "NOT NICE".... Globalism MUST BE REJECTED, and Carney is the Globalist puppet of the City of London.

Expand full comment
Ner Ther's avatar

Oh thank GOD for that, or I wouldn't be here. We immigrated to Canada in the early 1950's.

Expand full comment
Ner Ther's avatar

But still, Canada could definitely have strict entrance policies. It seems to me we have none.

Expand full comment
Lawrence Clooney's avatar

Didn't Trump back Carney in the 2025 Canada Federal election?

Expand full comment
susan gerbes's avatar

I think Trump did a great job of playing Carnage....he knows Carnage is a wimp and could eat him alive.....

Expand full comment
Tatanka's avatar

who would want to eat that poison?

Expand full comment
susan gerbes's avatar

why was the Canadian election all about Trump anyway????

Expand full comment
John's avatar
Nov 22Edited

It’s because of TDS caused by Media brainwashing. The liberal/communist media use the methods of the CIA. These methods have been used many times in the past. One example from 1920 when the architect of communism in China , Grigori N Voitinski a Russian Jewish Bolshevik, helped China usher in Communism in 1920s. One of the first things this Bolshevik did was take control of all the newspapers of the day. Then spread his communist propaganda to destabilize the government. Then he had his minions infiltrate the schools where they brainwashed the youth of the day……Sound familiar? How many members of the Trudeau foundation, when Trudeau was in power, from 2015 were influenced by China? Interestingly donations from non Canadian sources went from $53 million to $535 million between 2014 and 2016. That is why Canada has become a mess. IMO

Expand full comment
Brent's avatar

John you nailed it!

Expand full comment
Ner Ther's avatar

You would have to ask the Ontario Liberals that question.

Expand full comment
John's avatar

Trump thought by supporting Carney, Canadians would vote conservative; Trump wanted the conservatives to win. IMO

Expand full comment
Brent's avatar

I agree, your statement is proof of the utter stupidity in the minds of Canadians. I hate Trump, but I will vote for his endorsement, I am embarrassed to admit I am Canadian, because I live among so much ignorance!

Expand full comment
Lawrence Clooney's avatar

If that's the case, Trump needs to hire me onto the US intelligence teams working the Canada portfolio. I look good in a white sheet. BOO!

Expand full comment
Delores McNee's avatar

Because Trump knew Carney would not stand up to him regarding tariffs. Being a career, Poilieve knows how to do the best for Canada. Carney is all for his own pocket like Trudeau was!

Expand full comment
John Nolan's avatar

The same Trump who threatened to terminate our trade negotations because Ford "interfered in US politics"? If it is, I guess there's more than one leader in the western world who talks out of both sides of his face.

Expand full comment
Karen W.'s avatar

And he would be correct!

Expand full comment
Derek Holshorst's avatar

Not could be he is a 100% right on this.

Expand full comment
Karen W.'s avatar

I said would be not could be

Expand full comment
David's avatar

Canada has become a Flibbertigibbet nation. Inundating itself with citizenry other nations do not want for good reason. Draining it/s own financial resources to keep those immigrants on perpetual welfare even while employed? Subsidizing 85% of wages paid to immigrants. Private business laying off Canadian born employees to live in homeless camps while the Government subsidizes non-citizens with free loans to start businesses and to buy vehicles. Canada's fiscal behavior is simply - Leftist insanity. The government is now using up it's national public pension fund to support immigrants - and telling those who paid the pension "We will owe you don't worry

And the government owned media refuses to report on the ongoing Train Wreck.

Expand full comment
Brenda's avatar

All part of the WEF elitist plan.

Expand full comment
William Stewart's avatar

The USA has a lot of experience in "Unchecked" immigration..

Demonrats and Lieberals are cut from the same cloth and follow the same playbook.

The difference is the currently America is at least making an attempt to fix things.

Not so in what used to be Canada.

The BS being perpetrated upon this once wonderful country OF COURSE is not going unnoticed by others including the Americans.

It is being done to us intentionally.

Remember... We had a working and respected immigration system up until the idiots, fools and morons in this country fell for a total fraud's "SUNNY WAYS" BS.

The theme.. BS is all the Liberals are about.

Worse... Now we have an even bigger fraud, liar and fake, "Proud European", ex (if you believe him) WEF major player, UN major player, Globalist, Environmentalist, off-shore money hider and tax avoided, US investing and occasional visitor to Parliament as our PM.

Nothing to see here though since there is now little to nothing left of what used to be Canada.

Our current PM is simply here (elbows somewhere) to finish off the job the jerk with the weird sock fetish started in 2015.

By the looks of things so far... Right on track to do exactly that.

Expand full comment
Derek Holshorst's avatar

Agree with you, been saying this right from the start that Canada is taking the wrong direction with the Lying Liberals. But I feel to see that our voters are going to change, they like the Liberanos.

Expand full comment
William Stewart's avatar

YEP...

I no longer reside in Canada although I do come back to visit quite a bit.

Where I am one is not afraid to say what one is thinking.

Those where I live are happy to listen and even debate you if they do not agree.

They are civilized and even if different politically get it.

Then again... It's not really that urban, more urban-ish and they do have a great deal of respect for their constitution (unlike a lot of their other citizens in larger areas).

A constitution I might add that has value and is basically enforceable.

As opposed to the pretty much meaningless thing Canada has that it calls it's Charter of Rights and Freedoms which currently, as interpreted by Liberals and Judges grants Canadian Citizens neither rights nor freedoms.

What a great shame.

Canada had so very much potential and I wish for that to be accomplished perhaps down the road but hold out little hope.

As I said...

What a great shame.

Thank a Liberal and those who voted and vote for them.

OH... And fake Conservatives and in places like Ontario there are no shortage of those either.

Expand full comment
JBen's avatar

Time for Alberta Independence. We would be one of the most Prosperous and Free Nations on earth. We would have a higher GDP per capital than 97% of all Nations. We would be the Masters of our own Destiny. Check out the facts at albertaprosperityproject.com

Expand full comment
MarianneG's avatar

but you'd still be landlocked...

Expand full comment
Ner Ther's avatar

Not only landlocked, however the Indigenous People would soon claim it as their land.

Expand full comment
JBen's avatar

… and your point is?

Expand full comment
MarianneG's avatar

You still won't be able to get the oil out of the province.

Expand full comment
James Turner's avatar

Not a big fan of Vance, but in this instance, he is 100% correct. Canada's current problems large and small, are of its own making. Trump may be contributing, but how much of that is due to Trudeau's sleazy, behind the back insults to Trump - caught on camera for the world to see.

And/or the Liberal's bowing to Quebec again and refusing to negotiate their Supply Management System on dairy and poultry?

Expand full comment
John S.'s avatar

Why do you feel you need to make the first point in your comment? To say you really dislike him but you like what he is saying is such a silly non-sequitur. I can safely say this much, you do not know the man personally. You only know what the MSM says about him and that, friend, is probably as far from the truth as you can get.

Expand full comment
Jack Burley's avatar

I wish our corrupt liberal government was as honest or truthful like you Mr. Vance. We have a GREEN banker who apparently is looking after his own interests and forgetting us Canadians. Doesn`t he have family living in the USA? After 10 years, he came back to help Canada? The Easter Bunny comes tomorrow too! Can anyone tell me what he has done for Canadians since his return?

Expand full comment
John Nolan's avatar

What he has done is convinced a lot of idiots to waste their votes. What's unfortunate is that Trump didn't clip his elbows before the race.

Expand full comment
Jack Burley's avatar

Amen to the wasting their votes! And Trump!

Expand full comment
David James's avatar

Liberal mission? Kill Canada.

Expand full comment
Richard Courtemanche's avatar

Indeed, we have unstable people at the wheel.

Expand full comment
gary curtain's avatar

I hate to say it but Vance is right. The liberals have ruined the Canada we once knew. It's about time Canadians woke up and got rid of the liberals.

Expand full comment
J. Meyer's avatar

I'd like to say it was just the Liberals but Mulroney was the one who really kicked mass immigration and globalism/free trade into high gear.

Initially he pocketed - literally - $400,000 in cash but got millions after he left office through directorships and consultancies. I'm sure Carny has a similarly rosy post-office path laid out.

Expand full comment
Eva Smillie's avatar

We tried that already ...

Expand full comment
Geoffrey Fidler's avatar

Canada is one of the easiest countries to enter and this is devaluing our passports. Lack screening / control is unacceptable and risks our safety and overwhelms our housing and health care. Carney will let millions in as he hides his support for the 2100 club lead by Mr. Wise. They are ruining our culture and standard of living. JD is correct

Expand full comment
Tracy Matts's avatar

He is 100% correct

Expand full comment
Doug Stephens's avatar

Instead of stagnating I'd say Canada is in a deathspiral.

Expand full comment
Wanda Lambert's avatar

100% agree.

Expand full comment
Ms Smith's avatar

Yes, I believe he is right.

Expand full comment
J. Meyer's avatar

JD is at least 100% correct on the impacts of mass immigration. It is amazing that this policy is still being followed. The lobby group Century Initiative is quarterbacking this and Carney is a supporter. Here is an article on the duplicity of Canada's politicians and investment banker owned media.

https://sustainablesociety.com/the-globe-and-mail-goes-full-alan-oops-greenspan-on-immigration/

Expand full comment
Rob Ollerenshaw's avatar

If I'm not mistaken, Century Initiative thinks we should stuff 100 million people in Canada, because "we have the room". Goes right along with 'you will own nothing and you will be happy'. Rainbow dust, pixies and unicorns.

Expand full comment
J. Meyer's avatar

Not " Rainbow dust, pixies and unicorns.", just massive profits for speculators, developers and banks.

Expand full comment
Rob Ollerenshaw's avatar

And our PM is one of those you mention. Fancy that! Brookfield...nice pastoral, peaceful name don't you think? Those who think Carney wanted to be PM for the salary would be stunned to know what he is making behind the scenes. And he chooses who is the watchdog over him? What could go wrong with that?

Expand full comment
Lorrie Royce's avatar

The USA is not Canada’s problem. Canada is Canada’s problem. Weak leadership and anti-economic growth causesd by the current Govt is our problem.

Expand full comment
James Turner's avatar

Clear, concise, and accurate. Well said.

Expand full comment
Concerned Male's avatar

Not a fan of Vance or Trump but he is right!

Expand full comment
David James's avatar

"Might?"

Expand full comment
{Logan} Untitled's avatar

Since when does the friggin indian tell the country what to do. He was defeated and fed. White Christian Europeans built this country. Nothing existed before our ancestors built it. Time to kick these welfare cases aside, and get on with business. Bulldoze their tepees and send them packing.

Expand full comment