8 Comments
User's avatar
Paul T.'s avatar

A lot of faux Indians all over this country. I once visited a reserve to buy some pot plants. I guess that makes me Indigenous...Can I now wear a culturally appropriated Haida Indian tattoo like Justin Trudeau? What makes one man an Indian today makes another man a liar and racist tomorrow. BTW: Where are the 215 bodies?

Bernie F's avatar

This is why the whole identity industry (belonging to an identifiable group) is nonsense. Even if he had Cherokee ancestry, why does that make what he says more true/accurate? Take things people say and or have lived through at face value and determine if true or accurate, why does it matter what you identify as?

Jennifer's avatar

If Canada's (and USA's) indigenous are so oppressed and mistreated, why are non-indigenous caught appropriating that heritage so frequently?

Priscilla Schwartz's avatar

It must be lucrative to claim Indian status today.

Wayne Robinson's avatar

When you have written accounts then you something to discuss !! When you have verbal stories then that is all you have are stories no evidence .

Andrew's avatar

Saul Bellow quotes:

"Who is the Tolstoy of the Zulus? The Proust of the Papuans? I’d be glad to read him."

"Where is Africa's Shakespeare? Where is the Zulu Tolstoy?"

So no surpise this writer isn't Indian.

Anthony Tasker's avatar

Will he be alright?